Review: Annie Get Your Gun

10th March 2010

Image Post #16153

Tuesday 9th – Saturday 20th, 7.45 with matinees at 2.30 on Saturdays at The ADC Theatre. £6-10.

Directed by Ben Kavanagh. 


There's no people like show people. Except when they're students, pretending to be show people. Pale, English students barely out of their teens, with a joke shop wardrobe and a limited props budget to work with. Somehow working to summon the spirit of the American Wild West. 

I'm not the biggest fan of musicals. There's something very false about them, whether it’s the tuneless schlocky romantic songs, the preachy sentiment or the three-hour fixed grins of chorus members. But what can lift them out of terminal tackiness and boredom is the spirit and energy people willingly put into such productions. Where production values and showbiz experience fail, spirit will sometimes pull them through. And Annie Get Your Gun has this spirit in spades.

Don't think I'm about to come over all aww shucks on you; the musical most certainly has its flaws. The late intermission seemed ill-judged, leaving a second half abruptly short where the first had dragged into oblivion. The costumes, as aforementioned, were cringey, bordering on Village People. It's tough outfitting a twenty-strong cast old-fashioned cowboys and Indians, as well as waiters, debutantes and various crooning train attendants. But the Indian outfits in particular might have come straight from the jokeshop; the chorus resembled members of a racially insensitive pub crawl.

The cast was similarly patchy; James Sharpe is usually wonderful, but his American accent (in a standard 'Befuddled Bar-room Proprietor' role as Foster Wilson) was ropey as a faulty lasso, sometimes letting slip rounded English vowels, other times lapsing into a ludicrously phlegmy Batman bellow. Will Karani played lead Frank Butler as a (barely) animated Ken doll; he looked the part but was no match for scene-devouring Charlotte Reid as Annie. Reid looks and sounds like an ADC Miley Cyrus, cheesy and unfailingly charming as the benign face of gun crime. With her distinctly un-Cambridge megawatt smile, she has the voice and the boundless energy of a genuine star. Another performer worth mentioning was Liane Grant as showgirl reject Dolly; her perfectly deadpan timing made her the ideal foil for Reid's chipper heroine.

Sleepier audience members were shocked into waking by the sound effects; this play contains more full-volume gunshot blasts than a 2002-era Nas record. Sitting in the second row I wondered if my eardrums would survive each time Annie reached for the titular shotgun. Similarly camp, kitschy design is ideal for a musical like this one, but the bizarre and poorly-painted 'Big Top' backdrop (complete with an oddly anatomical opening in its centre) seemed shoddy and out of place.

Still it's solidly entertaining and delivered with relish, if you like the sound of men in mascara and cowboy hats, musical standards like 'Anything You Can Do',  and a half-hearted 'feminist' message.

 

2.5/5 stars

Annie Get Your Gun, ADC Theatre 9-20th March, 7.45

No related articles.

12 Responses to “Review: Annie Get Your Gun”

  1. girton says:

    If you don't like musicals then maybe you're not the most objective person to write a review about one. Play to your strengths

  2. Costume Assistant says:

    "It's tough outfitting a twenty-strong cast old-fashioned cowboys and Indians, as well as waiters, debutantes and various crooning train attendants." – you have NO idea…

  3. luvie says:

    I too was in the audience last night and,whilst it certainly was not without its flaws ,I really enjoyed the performance as did most of the audience to judge by laughter/applause.'Annie' certainly stole the show but some very nice performances from other cast members. 'Frank Butler' has a sublime voice and although I would have preferred more animation in the first half, the contrast in the second showed, to me, that he had been directed that way. Criticisms I have are technical, lighting etc. As previously stated why review something you have no love for, and therefore presumably little experience of ?

  4. Bitch Cassidy says:

    as the most populist form of theatre, musicals should win over the haters regardless. sounds like she was being objective, sometimes its better to lay your cards on the table, right? anyway she IS playing to her strength. this 'Kiberd' girl has style.

  5. grandmamolly says:

    I saw it last night and thought it enjoyable hokum, as musical theatre ought to be. Charlotte Reid was excellent, as she indeed should be, but I liked others too. Will Kirani had a great voice and was really 'fit' according to my teenage daughter! The lullaby song with 'barber shop' was brilliant as were many others in the chorus. I do hope the cast dont read your review, they might think you know what you're talking about :)

  6. Leila says:

    and that person you calling fit is my boy friend…

  7. sugarpuffdaddy says:

    Come, come! A review is at most an opinion; this is a reasonably, although certainly not generously, balanced opinion. However, as someone who has both given and received a few in his time,reviews are better made when all has been seen and not in the interval bar! Walls (and bars) have ears m'dear!

  8. Yawn. says:

    'I dont know much about musicals, but…'
    'I don't know much about dance, but…'
    'I don't know much about comedy, but…'

    Standard Cambridge review.

  9. Random says:

    I went to see it last night – thought it was great. Some very creative direction considering the small stage at the ADC, also thought the two leads (especially Annie) were fantastic, but stand out perfomance was the guy playing Sitting Bull, although it utterly un PC, his dead pan manner combined with his costume reminded me of something from the might boosh. Possibly not the intended effect, but I enjoyed it!

  10. Lolage says:

    Saw it on Saturday and I have to say, 'Barely animated Ken doll'? The guy playing Frank played it perfectly and had a voice which wouldn't have been out of place in the West end. Annie was incredible as well.

Leave a Reply